Politics16 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed Everyone is arguing over whether a 'voice but no vote' on EU food rules is a humiliation or a compromise. Neither side has noticed that it is the traditional British method of running almost everything.
Everyone else: Having a voice but no vote on EU food rules is either a national humiliation or a grudging, pragmatic compromise.
Politics16 Nov 2026Disagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposed The Milburn review proposes to make under-25s cheaper to employ and harder to leave idle. It has carefully examined the wrong generation.
Everyone else: Britain's young people are in crisis, and the answer is to make them cheaper to employ and harder to leave idle.
Politics16 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The Conservatives propose to rescue children from screens and artificial intelligence with paper and textbooks. This is admirable, but it stops several centuries too soon.
Everyone else: Swapping screens for pens, paper and textbooks is either welcome common sense or nostalgic Luddism dressed up as policy.
Politics14 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed Everyone agrees the walkout threatens the early release scheme. The real danger to ministers is that, for once, someone might find out whether the scheme's central assumption ever worked.
Everyone else: The walkout is a serious blow to ministers' prison policy and shows how overstretched the probation service has become.
Politics14 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed Alan Milburn wants every young person guaranteed a job or a training place. Nobody appears to have asked what this means for the covering letter.
Everyone else: A guaranteed job or training place sounds like a sensible, compassionate fix for youth unemployment.
Politics13 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The Prime Minister says closer ties with Brussels could be the Brexit people actually voted for. He is correct, but he has stopped at the halfway house when the logic demands the full return journey.
Everyone else: Remainers welcome a sensible reset with Europe, while Brexiteers see betrayal dressed up as fulfilment.
Business13 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The UK grew by 0.7 per cent in the third quarter, and the credit has gone to artificial intelligence. Constitutional propriety demands that the credit, and the box, go with it.
Everyone else: The growth figures are welcome but fragile, and may well fizzle out by winter.
Britain12 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The Culture Secretary wants broadcasters, studios and publishers to protect whistleblowers or face the law. The aim is right. I fear the remedy will soon join the long list of things everybody in the business knows about and nobody mentions.
Everyone else: An industry that treated abuse as an 'open secret' must finally be forced to clean up its act, and a minister is right to summon executives for a showdown.
Business12 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed MPs are outraged that millions were taken out of Poundland. They have failed to ask why a pound shop was ever worth millions in the first place.
Everyone else: A beloved high-street bargain shop has been asset-stripped by its owner, and its loss would be another blow to struggling town centres.
Politics11 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The Conservative leader's slogan has been treated as rhetoric. Read as a corporate structure chart, it points to a very different disposal from the one she proposes.
Everyone else: Kemi Badenoch's £36bn welfare cuts are a bold, defining gamble, whether you consider them overdue toughness or cruelty dressed as tough love.
Politics11 Nov 2026Disagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposed The cabinet secretary wants a bolder, more proactive civil service. Before anyone signs off on this, somebody ought to ask what the existing one has been so carefully preventing.
Everyone else: Whitehall is sluggish, cautious and overdue for a shake-up, and the cabinet secretary deserves applause for saying so.
Britain11 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The heir to the throne's estate plans to raise £500m by selling farms to the people who work them. Critics and supporters are both missing the scandal, which is that it took a fourteenth-century landlord to manage it.
Everyone else: The Duchy of Cornwall sell-off is either a royal cashing in at tenants' expense or a modernised estate sensibly raising funds.
Politics9 Nov 2026Disagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposed The zero-emission mandate is expected to be cut this week, to howls from both sides. Both have missed that a target emits nothing, costs nothing and can be revised downwards forever without harming a single hedgerow.
Everyone else: Cutting the electric vehicle sales targets is either a betrayal driven by carmaker lobbying or long-overdue realism.
Society9 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The government is considering keeping under-16s off second-hand selling sites from next March. It has not asked who is being protected from whom.
Everyone else: Barring under-16s from Vinted and eBay is either sensible protection from scams or a nanny-state attack on teenage thrift.
Politics8 Nov 2026Disagreement: 3 out of 5, opposed The prime minister's talk of rejoining assumes our old membership can simply be reactivated. Anyone who has tried to recover a dormant email account knows otherwise.
Everyone else: Rejoiners call it overdue, Leavers call it betrayal, and Westminster agrees it will be a long, bumpy road through Brussels.