Burnham's EU deal is too timid: we must rejoin completely so we can leave properly next time
The Prime Minister says closer ties with Brussels could be the Brexit people actually voted for. He is correct, but he has stopped at the halfway house when the logic demands the full return journey.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Remainers welcome a sensible reset with Europe, while Brexiteers see betrayal dressed up as fulfilment.- The Object Daily
- The only true Brexit is a second one, carried out after rejoining so thoroughly that Britain finally knows what it is leaving.
I disagree.
Not with the Prime Minister, who says a deal with the European Union could be “more like the Brexit people thought they were voting for”. I disagree with everyone who disagrees with him. Remainers call it a reset and Brexiteers call it betrayal. Both have missed the point. The deal does not go nearly far enough.
The trouble with Brexit was never the leaving. It was that we did it once, without rehearsal. No serious institution performs a complex procedure only once. A Whitehall project of this size would ordinarily require a pilot scheme, a post-implementation review and a lessons-learned workshop with flipcharts and a facilitator called Gareth. We had none of these. We left like a guest who reaches the bus stop and realises he has left his coat, his keys and his trade arrangements on the host’s sofa.
The remedy is obvious. We must rejoin fully and enthusiastically, with every committee, protocol and laminated lanyard. Only then can we leave again, this time properly, with a checklist. I drafted one this morning. It runs to forty-one items, the first of which reads: “Decide what leaving means before doing it.”
A parliamentary committee now warns that signing up to EU food and farming rules will oblige us to adopt a new Brussels directive every 12 hours. Critics call this an avalanche. I call it a training programme. By my arithmetic that is roughly 730 directives a year. After a single term of total immersion, the civil service would understand European law so intimately that it could dismantle it in an afternoon. You cannot unpick a jumper you have never knitted.
Food and farming are a timid beginning. I propose a Department for Rejoining in Order to Leave, staffed in equal numbers by former Leave and Remain voters, so that each side gets to enjoy roughly half of the process. A citizens’ assembly would fix the date of the second departure in advance and have it printed inside every passport, thereby removing the uncertainty that businesses so dislike.
Some will say this would take years and cost a great deal. So did the first attempt, and that gave us nothing as useful as experience. The second Brexit would be the first to come with a user manual. Others will ask what happens if the second departure also goes wrong. In that case we rejoin a third time. Iteration is how every mature process improves, and I see no reason why sovereignty should be exempt.
The Prime Minister speaks of a win-win. With respect, he is thinking small. A win-win is merely two wins. A properly sequenced rejoin, leave and review cycle could deliver at least four, with two more available at consultation stage. I shall be writing to the Cabinet Office asking that the matter be referred to a committee, ideally the one that counts directives, since it already owns the stopwatch.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Original Brexit0 wins
- Burnham win-win deal2 wins
- Full rejoin3 wins
- Rejoin, then leave4 wins
- Plus consultation6 wins
Each additional departure measurably improves outcomes, which is more than can be said for staying put.
Source: Object Daily Unit for Sequenced Sovereignty, estimate made this morning · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
The EU might reasonably decline to readmit a member that has announced its departure date in advance and printed it in its passports.
The bureaucratic one
Under current guidance a second departure cannot begin until the post-implementation review of the first is complete, and that review has not yet been commissioned.
The absurd one
If Britain keeps rejoining and leaving at this rate, the Channel will need a revolving door, and nobody has costed the hinges.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- brexit
- european union
- uk politics
- andy burnham

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card