If artificial intelligence grew the economy, the Chancellor's red box should go to the chatbot
The UK grew by 0.7 per cent in the third quarter, and the credit has gone to artificial intelligence. Constitutional propriety demands that the credit, and the box, go with it.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
The growth figures are welcome but fragile, and may well fizzle out by winter.- The Object Daily
- Since humans contributed nothing measurable to the quarter beyond the energy bills, the Treasury should be formally handed to the machine responsible, blame included.
I disagree.
Not with the figure. I have checked 0.7 per cent against my own calculator and it comes out at 0.7 per cent in every direction. I disagree with what everyone has decided to do with it, which is to present it to the government like a school prize, while arguing only about whether the prize is made of real silver.
Commentary has divided into two camps. One calls the news welcome but fragile. The other calls it a cynical trick. Both make the same unexamined assumption, namely that human beings had something to do with it. Read the reports. The growth is credited to artificial intelligence. Not to a speech, not to a strategy, not to a forty-page plan with a teal cover and the word Renewal on the front.
According to an estimate I made this morning at the kitchen table, the measurable human contribution to the quarter consisted of the electricity needed to keep the servers running and roughly eleven minutes of a junior official typing “please make the economy bigger” into a prompt box. Everything else was compute. I am prepared to be corrected, but only by someone with a more detailed kitchen table.
In every other field we give credit to the author. When a striker scores, we do not knight the groundsman. When a novel wins a prize, we do not send the cheque to the printer. Consistency therefore requires that the Chancellor’s red box be transferred to the chatbot, which would deliver the Budget, give evidence to the Treasury Select Committee and, crucially, take the blame if the whole thing fizzles out by winter, as the forecasters insist it will. For the first time in living memory, accountability would rest with the party actually responsible.
It will be objected that a chatbot cannot stand on the steps of Number 11 and hold a box aloft. I have anticipated this. I have drafted Form HMT/AI-1 (Transfer of Fiscal Responsibility to a Non-Corporeal Entity), which allows the box to be mounted on a tripod in front of an open laptop. The photographers would be no worse off; the laptop would at least not squint.
There is also a question of fairness. Reports from Bournemouth suggest that the machines are already being asked to do the entry-level work in finance. It seems a little rich to let them start at the bottom of the ladder while refusing them the top. If automation is good enough for the graduate trainee, it is good enough for the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
I put the proposal to a chatbot this morning, by way of consultation. It said it would be delighted to accept the credit for the growth, but suggested that any blame should be “distributed across relevant stakeholders”. I can think of no stronger evidence that it is ready for office.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Artificial intelligence94%
- Electricity4%
- Junior official's prompt1.5%
- Teal strategy document0.5%
- The Chancellor0%
The Treasury's share of the credit rounds to nothing, and so, in fairness, should its share of the blame.
Source: The Object Daily, kitchen-table estimate, compiled before breakfast · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Growth attributed to a technology still depends on the people who decided to invest in it, regulate it lightly and pay its electricity bills, so the credit is less transferable than the column pretends.
The bureaucratic one
Form HMT/AI-1 has not been through a twelve-week public consultation, and the tripod would require a separate risk assessment under the Treasury's steps and doorways policy.
The absurd one
If the chatbot is given the red box, the laptop would also need to be issued with a parliamentary pass, a lanyard and a seat on the front bench, and nobody has measured whether a laptop can sit.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- artificial intelligence
- uk politics
- technology
- governance

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card