A legal job guarantee would rob young Britons of their forty formative rejections
Alan Milburn wants every young person guaranteed a job or a training place. Nobody appears to have asked what this means for the covering letter.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
A guaranteed job or training place sounds like a sensible, compassionate fix for youth unemployment.- The Object Daily
- Being turned down by forty employers is the last surviving British rite of passage, and it should not be abolished by statute without at least a consultation.
I disagree.
Not with the compassion, which is admirable, nor with the arithmetic, which I leave to the Treasury, who enjoy it. I disagree because a statutory guarantee of a job or training place for every young person would abolish, at a stroke and without consultation, the last surviving rite of passage available to the British adolescent: being turned down by forty employers in a row.
Other cultures have initiation ceremonies involving a long walk alone, or a period of fasting. We have the applicant tracking portal. Generations of young Britons have been formed by it. They have uploaded a CV, then been asked to retype the same CV into seventeen separate boxes, then been invited to describe a time they showed resilience, which by question nine they were demonstrably doing. They have learned that “we will be in touch” is a statement about the general possibility of contact in the universe rather than a commitment.
Above all, they have learned to write the covering letter. Nobody is born able to write the covering letter. It is acquired, painfully, over many months, until the young person can produce four paragraphs in the tone of a hostage reading a prepared statement: grateful, upbeat and passionate about the logistics sector. By an estimate I made this morning with a biro, the average candidate reaches full hostage fluency at around rejection twenty-six. Remove the rejections and you remove the fluency. We will raise a generation able to say plainly what they want, which no British workplace is equipped to receive.
Consider, too, the employers. Many organisations, I suspect, retain somebody whose sole function is not replying. A legal guarantee would oblige someone, somewhere, to say yes. I have seen the proposal only as reported, and I see nothing in it about retraining the people whose careers have been built on silence. Is there to be a guarantee for them?
Then there is the money, which is to come from a radical shift in spending away from benefits for young people. I take no view on whether this is wise. I merely assume that somebody will need a form to confirm a young person has been guaranteed something, a second form to confirm they have received it, and a third, which I have provisionally numbered JG-41b, on which they may declare that they were not, in fact, rejected, and would like this noted for character-building purposes.
I am not against young people having work. I am against them having it without first having earned the right to be ignored. If Parliament must legislate, let it do so honestly. Let the guarantee be preceded by a statutory minimum of forty rejections, each delivered by automated email at 11.47pm and each beginning “Unfortunately, on this occasion”. Only then, battle-hardened and fluent in passive gratitude, may the young person take up their guaranteed place.
They will thank us. Probably in a covering letter.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
Fluency peaks at rejection twenty-six and collapses entirely the moment anyone is guaranteed anything.
Source: Estimate made this morning with a biro, The Object Daily · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Rejection teaches very little if it comes as silence; a guaranteed placement might teach the far rarer skill of actually doing a job, which no covering letter has ever conveyed.
The bureaucratic one
The forty-rejection requirement would need a central register of rejections, a definition of what counts as one, and an appeals process for applicants who suspect they were only rejected thirty-nine times.
The absurd one
If the young are deprived of rejection, they will simply seek it elsewhere, and the nation's dating apps are not resourced for the surge.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- welfare
- uk politics
- education
- bureaucracy

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card