Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026Vol. 1 · No. 9 · Price: one objection
PoliticsLeader · SatireObjection

The young have read the labour market correctly; it is the over-fifties who need a review

The Milburn review proposes to make under-25s cheaper to employ and harder to leave idle. It has carefully examined the wrong generation.

2 min readDisagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposedWhat actually happened? ↓
Everyone else
Britain's young people are in crisis, and the answer is to make them cheaper to employ and harder to leave idle.
The Object Daily
The under-25s have rationally assessed the labour market, and the true crisis is the over-fifties who still turn up to work every day without asking why.

I disagree.

The Milburn review, to be launched this week, proposes to make the under-25s cheaper to employ by gradually reducing National Insurance over five years, and to catch those who slip through with a ‘benefits backstop’. The Prime Minister promises a root-and-branch rethink. I welcome a rethink. I simply suggest that it begin at the other end of the tree.

The entire exercise rests on an assumption that nobody has thought to test: that young people ought to want the jobs on offer. Consider the labour market as it presents itself to a nineteen-year-old. It contains open-plan offices, a pension described in the tone usually reserved for a distant comet, and a line manager who sends emails at 11.42pm with the subject line ‘quick one’. A cohort that has examined this and hesitated is not in crisis. It is conducting due diligence.

I should be clear that some young people are unwell, or frightened, or have been badly let down, and they deserve proper help rather than a leader column. Mr Burnham himself writes that the situation is not their fault. I agree, and for the remainder would go further. It is not a fault at all. It is the first sign in decades of a generation reading the small print.

The real crisis lies elsewhere. According to an estimate I made this morning on a delayed train, 97 per cent of people over fifty arrived at work today without being asked twice. It is a Monday. They will attend a meeting to agree the agenda for a second meeting, and at no point in thirty years have they paused to assess the market. They have simply kept turning up, which economists call loyalty and I call a failure of price discovery.

I therefore propose a mirror-image review. An Interdepartmental Working Group on Unexamined Diligence would require every employee over fifty to complete Form ATT-50, the Declaration of Continued Attendance, setting out in no more than 400 words why they came in. Those unable to offer a reason other than ‘it’s Monday’ would be referred to a backstop of their own: a guaranteed afternoon off, enforceable at law.

Mr Milburn has argued that young people should have a legal guarantee of a job or training. I would offer the over-fifties a legal guarantee of a sit-down. The young, having already worked out that the office will survive without them, could be invited in occasionally as consultants, at day rates, to explain this to the rest of us.

I would have made this case in person at the launch. Unfortunately I am fifty-four, and I have a meeting.

The Object Daily editorial board

The Object Daily Statistics OfficeFeels right. If you don't check.Arrival at work on a Monday without being asked twice, by age
  1. 16–2438%
  2. 25–3461%
  3. 35–4979%
  4. 50–6497%
  5. 65 and over99%
  6. Leader writers100%

Willingness to attend rises steadily with age, in inverse proportion to anyone having checked whether it is worth it.

Source: The Object Daily, estimate made on a delayed train, unweighted · Satire

Three further objections

  1. The reasonable one

    The over-fifties largely turn up because their mortgages and contributions fund the very backstop being offered to the young, so subtracting them from the workforce would collapse the Treasury's arithmetic before it reached the second year of the five-year taper.

  2. The bureaucratic one

    Form ATT-50 would itself require staff to process it, most of whom are over fifty and would therefore need to submit an ATT-50 before processing anyone else's, and the guidance on this recursion has not yet completed its twelve-week consultation.

  3. The absurd one

    The moment a young person accepts a consultancy day rate they become employed, forfeit their rationality, and must be referred straight back to the Milburn review.

Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

  • uk politics
  • welfare
  • andy burnham
  • bureaucracy
Quote card: Everyone else: Britain's young people are in crisis, and the answer is to make them cheaper to employ and harder to leave idle. The Object Daily: The under-25s have rationally assessed the labour market, and the true crisis is the over-fifties who still turn up to work every day without asking why.

The quote card

Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.

Share the quote card

We also disagree with