The Duchy sell-off is the land reform the left never dared to deliver
The heir to the throne's estate plans to raise £500m by selling farms to the people who work them. Critics and supporters are both missing the scandal, which is that it took a fourteenth-century landlord to manage it.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
The Duchy of Cornwall sell-off is either a royal cashing in at tenants' expense or a modernised estate sensibly raising funds.- The Object Daily
- It is the most radical redistribution of English farmland in living memory, and the real embarrassment belongs to every reformer who failed to get there first.
I disagree.
Not with the facts. The Duchy of Cornwall, the private estate that provides the heir to the throne’s income, intends to raise £500m over ten years by selling farms across England, and tenants may be offered the choice of buying the land they work or leaving it. Critics call this cashing in. Supporters call it modernisation. Both have overlooked what is plainly in front of them: this is land reform, and it is being carried out by the landlord.
Consider the history. For the better part of a century, earnest people have drafted proposals to put land in the hands of those who farm it. I have consulted my own index of conference motions, compiled this morning largely from memory, and estimate that the phrase land to the tiller has appeared in forty-one of them, each followed by referral to a working group.
The working group, where it reported at all, recommended a consultation. The consultation recommended a review. The review recommended that the matter be revisited after the next spending round, which by long-standing convention never arrives. Meanwhile the Duchy has produced a ten-year plan with a cash figure on the front. No green paper. No white paper. Not even a beige one.
Critics fix on the fact that tenants must pay, and I concede it is not ideal. But a reform delivered by the state would also have required payment, merely via Form AGR-7(b), Application for Agricultural Self-Ownership (Transitional), a stamp duty holiday expiring before the form is processed, and a new arm’s-length body, the Office for Tiller Affairs, with a regional structure, a diversity of stakeholders and a logo involving a stylised turnip.
The left, then, should be furious. Not at the Duchy for selling, but at itself for being beaten to the finish by an institution whose founding charter predates the printing press in England. The right should be equally uneasy. A property-owning democracy was supposed to be their slogan, and it is being implemented by someone who has never stood for election and is under no obligation to.
There is also the matter of inheritance. Those tenants who buy will acquire, along with the freehold, the full privilege of worrying about what becomes of it afterwards, a privilege until now reserved for the landlord. That is what equality looks like in the English countryside: the anxiety, finally, is shared.
I therefore propose that the Duchy be summoned before a select committee, not to be criticised but to explain to the assembled members how a decade-long structural reform can be announced without a single pilot scheme. If it can reorganise English land tenure in ten years, I see no reason it should not be asked to look at the planning system next. I suspect, however, that even the Duchy would want a working group for that.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Conference motion104 years
- Royal Commission87 years
- Consultation and review61 years
- Office for Tiller Affairs48 years
- Duchy ten-year plan10 years
The only method that delivers inside a generation is the one nobody voted for.
Source: The Object Daily index of conference motions, compiled this morning largely from memory · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Selling farms to sitting tenants at market value is not redistribution at all; it converts rent into mortgage debt, and those who cannot raise the money leave.
The bureaucratic one
Any reform of agricultural tenure must first be assessed against the 2019 Rural Proofing Guidance, which the Duchy, as a private estate, has not been asked to complete in triplicate.
The absurd one
If farmers own their farms, the sheep will reasonably expect a share of the freehold, and nobody has consulted the sheep.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- governance
- uk politics
- royal family
- farming

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card