Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026Vol. 1 · No. 9 · Price: one objection
PoliticsLeader · SatireObjection

Pens are the problem too: a truly conservative classroom would return to slate and chalk

The Conservatives propose to rescue children from screens and artificial intelligence with paper and textbooks. This is admirable, but it stops several centuries too soon.

3 min readDisagreement: 3 out of 5, opposedWhat actually happened? ↓
Everyone else
Swapping screens for pens, paper and textbooks is either welcome common sense or nostalgic Luddism dressed up as policy.
The Object Daily
The pledge is not backward-looking enough, since the pen and the printed book were the original threats to memory, and only slate, chalk and oral recitation will do.

I disagree.

Not with the diagnosis, which is impeccable, but with the date on the prescription. The Conservatives propose to halt screen-based exams in England, cut coursework and redirect money Labour is spending on educational technology into millions of pounds’ worth of new textbooks, on the grounds that screens and artificial intelligence are doing children’s thinking for them. I accept every word of that. What I cannot accept is the party’s apparent belief that the rot set in with the laptop.

It did not. It set in considerably earlier. Socrates warned that writing would implant forgetfulness in the soul, since people would trust marks outside themselves rather than memory within. He was, as far as I can establish, never invited to give evidence to the Education Select Committee, and we have been paying for it ever since. The quill was a disruptive technology. The steel nib was worse. The ballpoint pen, which allows a pupil to outsource a fact to the back of a hand in under four seconds, is a cognitive crutch of exactly the kind now attributed to chatbots, merely slower and blue.

The textbook is no better. The printed book is, if one is honest, the large language model of the fifteenth century: an enormous quantity of text the reader did not compose, available on demand, encouraging the habit of looking things up instead of knowing them. A party worried about over-reliance on AI is proposing to spend millions on the original over-reliance.

A genuinely conservative settlement would go back to slate, chalk and oral recitation. The slate is, after all, simply a screen with no battery, no notifications and a strictly enforced auto-delete policy. Nothing written on it survives long enough to be plagiarised. Oral examination, meanwhile, solves the coursework problem at a stroke, since one cannot cut what cannot physically exist. Ofqual would need a new marking framework; I have proposed grades 1 to 9 for recitation, with a 9 reserved for pupils who can deliver the periodic table without visibly consulting the ceiling.

Nor is this a costly reform. According to an estimate I made this morning, a single slate, amortised over the four decades it will survive a Year 9 class, costs less per term than the lid of a biro. Chalk is cheap, renewable and, unlike a tablet, cannot be updated overnight into something worse. Ofsted inspectors could carry out their work entirely by listening, which I am told several would prefer.

Critics will call this nostalgic Luddism. I would gently point out that the Luddites were early nineteenth-century figures who objected to machinery, which presupposes the existence of machinery. If we are to be nostalgic, we owe it to our children to be nostalgic thoroughly, and not to stop, as this pledge does, at roughly the point where their grandparents went to school.

I had intended to submit this column on slate, in keeping with its argument, but the production desk declined it on the grounds that it would not go through the scanner. I have therefore memorised it. Readers who agree are asked not to write in.

The Object Daily editorial board

The Object Daily Statistics OfficeFigures that could be trueVerses a pupil can recite, by the writing technology of the day

Verses per pupil

Memory has been in managed decline since the invention of the nib, and the Conservative pledge merely halts the fall at the ballpoint.

Source: The Object Daily estimate, compiled this morning without writing anything down · Satire

Three further objections

  1. The reasonable one

    Socrates' warning about writing survives only because Plato wrote it down, which rather suggests that the technology he distrusted is also the one that preserved the objection.

  2. The bureaucratic one

    Slates are not currently listed on the Department for Education's approved procurement framework, and adding them would require a twelve-week consultation, which would of course have to be conducted orally.

  3. The absurd one

    If we are going back to oral recitation, we should go further still and return to cave painting, which at least had the decency to be load-bearing.

Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

  • education
  • uk politics
  • technology
  • artificial intelligence
Quote card: Everyone else: Swapping screens for pens, paper and textbooks is either welcome common sense or nostalgic Luddism dressed up as policy. The Object Daily: The pledge is not backward-looking enough, since the pen and the printed book were the original threats to memory, and only slate, chalk and oral recitation will do.

The quote card

Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.

Share the quote card

We also disagree with

An even stronger objection

Disagreement 4 out of 5, against this article's 3

Politics9 Nov 2026Disagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposed

A weaker electric car target is the greenest policy this government has produced

The zero-emission mandate is expected to be cut this week, to howls from both sides. Both have missed that a target emits nothing, costs nothing and can be revised downwards forever without harming a single hedgerow.

Everyone else: Cutting the electric vehicle sales targets is either a betrayal driven by carmaker lobbying or long-overdue realism.