A voice without a vote is the finest influence Britain has ever had, and Westminster should have it too
Everyone is arguing over whether a 'voice but no vote' on EU food rules is a humiliation or a compromise. Neither side has noticed that it is the traditional British method of running almost everything.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Having a voice but no vote on EU food rules is either a national humiliation or a grudging, pragmatic compromise.- The Object Daily
- A voice without a vote is the purest form of British influence ever devised, and the government should be demanding it everywhere, starting at home.
I must object.
Not to the speech, which I am prepared to believe will be competently delivered, nor to Friday’s summit, which will take place whether I object or not. I object to the near-universal assumption that a ‘voice but no vote’ on EU food rules is a concession. One side calls it a humiliation, the other a pragmatic compromise. Both have mistaken it for a step down. It is, in fact, the most refined instrument of British influence ever developed, and we appear to be getting it at a discount.
Consider the record. The British have had a voice but no vote on the weather since records began. We discuss it every morning, at length and with considerable technical rigour. It has never once altered its plans. Nobody regards this as failure; it is the national conversation. The same is true of the railways, where millions of passengers have expressed firm views on the 07:42 without its arrival time being troubled in the slightest. And any parent of a teenager will confirm that a voice without a vote is not a constitutional anomaly but the ordinary condition of family life.
The vote, by contrast, is a burden. Once you have voted, you are responsible. A parliamentary committee has warned that adopting EU rules on food and farming would mean a new Brussels directive every 12 hours. With a vote, ministers would be obliged to read them. With a voice, they need only have opinions about them, which is far quicker and a skill Whitehall has spent centuries perfecting. According to an estimate I made over breakfast, the voice-only model saves roughly 0.7 of a junior minister per directive.
The EU minister, Hamish Falconer, insists that Britain would still have some influence. He is too modest. Influence without responsibility is not a lesser kind of power; it is the kind every columnist, backbencher and man at the end of the bar has always preferred. It allows one to be right about everything while being blamed for nothing.
I therefore find the Prime Minister’s three tests rather timid. Any agreement, we are told, must be consistent with Labour’s manifesto and the government’s red lines, improve the Brexit deal and pass the ‘Makerfield test’. I propose a fourth, which should take precedence over the others: does it give Britain a voice and spare it a vote? If not, the negotiators should return to the table until it does.
Nor should the principle stop at Brussels. The House of Commons spends a remarkable amount of time walking through division lobbies, an activity that produces exercise but very little contentment. MPs should keep their voices, their points of order and their indignation at Prime Minister’s Questions, and hand the votes to some neutral body that will ignore them with dignity. I suggest the weather. It has the experience.
I recognise that some readers will disagree with all of this, and I am delighted that they feel able to say so. Their views have been noted.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Tutting38%
- Remarks about weather24%
- Letters to the editor17%
- Consultation responses15%
- Actual votes6%
The vote accounts for a negligible share of British influence and could be surrendered without anyone noticing, least of all the weather.
Source: The Object Daily Unit for Influence Without Consequence, estimate made over breakfast · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
A voice is only influential if the people listening have some reason to care, and the weather has never needed British food exports.
The bureaucratic one
Transferring Commons votes to a meteorological phenomenon would require primary legislation, a Met Office impact assessment and confirmation that the weather is resident in the United Kingdom for tax purposes.
The absurd one
Teenagers have already lodged a formal objection, arguing that the voice-without-a-vote arrangement is their intellectual property and that Brussels must pay a licence fee to use it.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- brexit
- european union
- andy burnham
- uk politics

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card