Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026Vol. 1 · No. 9 · Price: one objection
PoliticsLeader · SatireObjection

Impeaching the Defence Secretary is the kindest thing Congress could do for his career

A forced House vote on Pete Hegseth is being read as the beginning of the end. It is, on any sober reading of the procedure, the beginning of the most secure employment in Washington.

2 min readDisagreement: 3 out of 5, opposedWhat actually happened? ↓
Everyone else
Pete Hegseth is finished, and Thomas Massie is either a principled constitutionalist or a traitor, depending on the channel.
The Object Daily
The safest place for any cabinet secretary is mid-impeachment, and Mr Massie has just put the Defence Secretary there.

I must object.

Not to the impeachment of the Defence Secretary, which is a matter for the House of Representatives, but to the near-universal assumption that the vote forced by Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky, which must take place by Wednesday, marks the end of Pete Hegseth’s time at the Pentagon. It marks, as far as I can tell, the start of the most secure period of employment available to anyone in Washington.

Consider the ordinary cabinet secretary, unburdened by articles of impeachment. He may be dismissed at any moment, without a hearing, a trial or so much as a covering letter, frequently before breakfast and occasionally by social media post. Now consider the impeached cabinet secretary. To dismiss him would be to concede that the House had a point. No president willingly concedes that the House had a point. Impeachment thus converts an at-will appointment into something approaching academic tenure, with the Senate acting as a sort of very slow-moving pensions committee.

The arithmetic only strengthens the case. Even if a depleted, lame-duck House approves the charges, conviction requires two-thirds of the Senate, a body that has never convicted a cabinet secretary. According to an estimate I made this morning on the back of a committee agenda, an ordinary secretary enjoying the president’s full confidence can expect roughly four further months in post. An impeached one can expect fourteen. One midway through a Senate trial, twenty-two. The president, who has already said Mr Hegseth should be praised rather than impeached, is now procedurally obliged to keep praising him until at least the closing arguments.

There is also what I can only call double jeopardy in spirit, if not in law. The Constitution does not forbid a second impeachment, but television does. Should Democrats attempt their own proceedings next year, as is widely expected, they will discover that the public regards an impeachment the way it regards a franchise: the second one is never as good, and nobody can remember the plot. Mr Massie has, in effect, used up the Defence Secretary’s sequel rights.

I make no claim about Mr Massie’s intentions, which he has stated clearly enough. I merely observe that intentions in Washington have a long record of producing their opposite, and that this appears to be a particularly efficient example.

The lesson for good government is obvious and, naturally, ignored. Every cabinet secretary should be placed under permanent, low-level impeachment as a condition of appointment. The Office of Personnel Management could issue a form, provisionally the SF-86-I, Declaration of Ongoing Articles, to be renewed annually. A standing select committee would keep the articles at a gentle simmer. Turnover would collapse, institutional memory would flourish and the Senate would finally have something to do in August.

In the interests of consistency, I have asked my editor to open impeachment proceedings against me. He has declined. I am choosing to take this as a warning.

The Object Daily editorial board

The Object Daily Statistics OfficeFigures that could be trueExpected remaining tenure of a cabinet secretary, by legal peril
  1. Full confidence4 months
  2. Publicly praised6 months
  3. Impeached by House14 months
  4. Mid Senate trial22 months
  5. Permanently impeached48 months

The surest route to a long career in the cabinet is to be charged with something, ideally slowly.

Source: The Object Daily estimate, compiled this morning on the back of a committee agenda · Satire

Three further objections

  1. The reasonable one

    An impeachment trial still drags damaging evidence into public view, and a secretary kept in post only to avoid conceding a point is protected in title while being weakened in practice.

  2. The bureaucratic one

    The proposed SF-86-I has not been through the Paperwork Reduction Act clearance process, and any standing select committee would require a resolution of the House, a budget line and an agreed definition of 'gentle simmer'.

  3. The absurd one

    If every secretary is permanently impeached, the Senate will run out of chairs for the trials, and the furniture procurement alone would require its own impeachment.

Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

  • us politics
  • congress
  • white house
  • governance
Quote card: Everyone else: Pete Hegseth is finished, and Thomas Massie is either a principled constitutionalist or a traitor, depending on the channel. The Object Daily: The safest place for any cabinet secretary is mid-impeachment, and Mr Massie has just put the Defence Secretary there.

The quote card

Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.

Share the quote card

We also disagree with