Wales's victory over New Zealand has destroyed a priceless national heritage asset
Seventy-three years of dignified defeat against the All Blacks were maintained at enormous cost by generations of Welsh players. They have been demolished in a single afternoon, without planning consent.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Beating New Zealand is a joyous, nation-lifting miracle that proves Welsh rugby is back from the dead.- The Object Daily
- The win is a cultural catastrophe, because the losing streak was a listed-grade national monument that Wales had no right to dismantle.
I disagree.
Not with the result, which I accept in the way one accepts weather. I disagree with the reaction. The BBC reports that Wales have gone “from no-hopers to heroes”, and nobody appears to have asked whether the no-hoping was doing anything important. It was. It was holding up roughly half the national character, and it has been removed without so much as a structural survey.
Consider what has been lost. A run of defeats stretching back to 1953 is not a losing streak; it is an inheritance. Three generations were raised on it. By an estimate I made this morning with a pencil and the back of a gas bill, it underpinned some 61 per cent of all Welsh sporting melancholy, a substantial share of the minor keys in circulation, and every conversation in a clubhouse that began with the words “we were so close”. These things do not regenerate. You cannot simply grow a new seventy-three years.
Cadw will list a bus shelter if it is old enough and sufficiently unloved. Here was a sequence of defeats older than most bus shelters, unbroken, lovingly maintained by successive squads at considerable personal discomfort. I therefore propose that the streak be listed retrospectively at Grade I, under the conservation principle that a heritage asset must be preserved as found. Saturday’s result, or whichever day it was, would then be reclassified as an unauthorised alteration and the Welsh Rugby Union served with an enforcement notice requiring reinstatement.
The Union also owes an apology to the nation’s poets, who have been made redundant overnight. Mourning is a skilled trade. It takes decades to learn how to grieve the All Blacks properly, and the profession has been given no notice, no transition period and no retraining scheme. I have drafted Form HL-53 (Heritage Loss) for affected writers. Section 4 asks claimants to “describe, in no more than 300 words, what you can no longer lament”. I expect the forms to be very beautiful and quite long.
I anticipate the objection that the nation has been lifted. Lifted to what, precisely? Winning is easy; any country can do it, and many do so every weekend without fuss. Losing nobly to the same opponent for seventy-three consecutive years requires institutions, patience and a national commitment to the long view. Wales had all three. It now has a single victory and the dreadful obligation of being expected to do it again, a burden for which nobody voted.
Nor has anyone considered the tourists. Visitors came, in part, to stand among a people who had made a dignified art of nearly. What will they find now? Cheerfulness. It is not what the brochures promised.
I do not ask for much. I ask for a public consultation, a select committee inquiry into how this was permitted, and, as an interim measure, that Wales lose the next fixture against New Zealand quietly and with good grace, purely out of respect for the dead streak. In the meantime I shall observe a minute’s silence in its memory. Being Welsh about it, I intend to sing it.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
A reserve built up over seventy-three years was liquidated in eighty minutes, with no plan for replenishment.
Source: The Object Daily Heritage Unit, from a gas bill and a pencil · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
A heritage that exists only so long as one side keeps losing is less a monument than a habit, and nations are generally allowed to change their habits.
The bureaucratic one
Cadw's listing criteria apply to structures and sites rather than sequences of results, so the application would first require a ruling on whether a losing streak counts as a building.
The absurd one
The streak is not lost but merely dormant, and can be revived by replaying the match backwards until 1953 is reached again.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- rugby
- wales
- heritage
- literature

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card