Impeaching the defence secretary is a luxury a lame-duck Congress simply cannot afford
Washington is busy debating whether removing Pete Hegseth would be right. Nobody has troubled to ask what it would cost, and the answer, by my own reckoning, is $41 million and a great deal of letterhead.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Democrats call the impeachment overdue oversight, Republicans call it a partisan stunt, and the cost-of-living caucus warns that it distracts from grocery prices.- The Object Daily
- Impeachment is not a question of accountability but of depreciation, and no prudent institution disposes of an asset halfway through its useful life.
I disagree.
Not with the Democrats, who call the impeachment of Pete Hegseth overdue oversight, nor with the Republicans, who call it a partisan stunt, nor with those who warn that it distracts from grocery prices. I disagree with all three at once, which is efficient, and efficiency is precisely what this week’s debate has lacked. Everyone is asking whether impeaching a defence secretary is right. Nobody has asked what it costs.
Begin with the stationery. In 2025 the Department of Defense acquired a second name, the Department of War. A successor, confirmed by a Senate in an oversight frame of mind, may well wish to undo this. According to an estimate I made this morning with the aid of a floor plan and a strong coffee, re-signing the Pentagon alone would cost $21 million, with a further $6 million for letterhead and lanyards. Should the successor’s successor prefer the war version again, the department ceases to be a department and becomes a subscription.
Then there is the matter of reading. A nominee confirmed in the current mood will be chosen precisely for reading briefings in full, including the annexes. Briefings are not free. Every annex requested generates a further annex, and every further annex requires an analyst to write it. I put the annual cost of a thoroughly diligent secretary at $9 million in additional analysts, before anyone has asked for a summary of the annexes, which they will.
The procedure itself is no bargain. Articles must be drafted, printed and carried across the Capitol, and should the matter ever reach a Senate trial, senators must be fed. All this in a lame-duck session that already contains a shutdown deadline, the farm bill and a debt ceiling fight. Commencing an impeachment in such conditions is like commissioning a new kitchen while the bailiffs are measuring the old one.
The grocery-price camp is therefore half right. Impeachment does not distract from grocery prices. It is grocery prices, scaled up to the federal level and paid for in letterhead. My total, including Senate catering, a portrait and a modest contingency, comes to $41 million.
There is a better way, and the treasury of any serious nation would recognise it. Cabinet secretaries should be treated as fixed assets and depreciated on a straight-line basis over a four-year term. No competent accountant disposes of an asset halfway through its useful life merely because he has developed reservations about it. He writes it down patiently, records his concerns in the margin, and waits until the book value reaches zero, at which point disposal is free.
I therefore urge Congress not to vote no, which would be complacent, nor yes, which would be ruinous, but to adopt a third option: a motion to impeach in arrears. I have written to the Congressional Budget Office requesting a score. I fully expect to be invoiced for it.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
Million dollars
- Pentagon re-signage21
- Annex-reading analysts9
- Letterhead and lanyards6
- Senate trial catering2.6
- Contingency2
- Portrait0.4
Signage alone accounts for more than half the bill, which is why the cheapest secretary is always the one already on the wall.
Source: The Object Daily, estimate made this morning with a floor plan and a strong coffee · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
An impeachment vote in the House removes nobody; conviction requires two-thirds of the Senate, so most of the columnist's replacement costs would almost certainly never be incurred.
The bureaucratic one
The federal asset register contains no category for 'Secretary, Cabinet-level, one', and a new depreciation schedule would first require a 90-day consultation and a GAO opinion on residual value.
The absurd one
The Pentagon has five sides, so every sign must be bought five times; moving the department into a triangle would cut re-signage costs by 40 per cent and settle the matter.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- us politics
- congress
- governance
- bureaucracy

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card