America's air traffic control was overwhelmed by being asked to do things, so stop asking
Officials blame old equipment that overloaded. The remedy is not billions in modernisation, which only invites more demand, but a firm national policy of asking it to do less.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
America's air traffic control system is dangerously antiquated, and Congress must spend billions modernising it as quickly as possible.- The Object Daily
- Friday's ground stop was caused by demand, not age, so the answer is to ask less of the system and to prohibit the modernisation that only raises expectations.
I disagree.
Not with the facts, which are grim enough and which I accept in full. Every departure in America was halted on Friday for more than four hours, thousands of flights have been cancelled into the weekend, and officials blame ageing equipment that overloaded. What I disagree with is the conclusion that has followed as reliably as a boarding announcement: that the system is antiquated, and that Congress must therefore spend billions modernising it as quickly as possible.
Consider what we are told about the machinery. It is old, it is antiquated and, by every official account, it overloaded. I would ask the select committee in my head to note that last word carefully. Equipment does not overload of its own accord. It overloads because somebody has asked it to do something, and then somebody else has asked it to do something as well. Age is merely a condition; demand is the culprit. The machinery was not too old for the job. The job was too insistent.
The modernisers’ remedy is to buy new equipment, faster, at a cost of billions. But new equipment does not reduce demand; it advertises capacity. Install a shinier system and airlines will schedule more flights, passengers will expect fewer delays, and everyone will ask more of it, until the new machinery is overloaded too, only more expensively. In any other field this would be called a dosage error. According to an estimate I made this morning on the back of a boarding pass, any intervention more ambitious than a light dusting carries a near-certain chance of somebody saying “that’s odd” within the hour. The answer is not to give the system more to work with. It is to give it less to do.
I therefore propose the Air Traffic Control (Preservation of Things That Work) Act, a short bill with a single operative clause: no person shall update, patch, upgrade, refresh or “migrate” any component of the national airspace system without first submitting Form ATC-0, on which the applicant must explain, in no more than fifty words, what precisely is wrong with it. A blank form is to be treated as a withdrawal. I anticipate a great many withdrawals.
Nor should we overlook the safety record of Friday afternoon. For more than four hours, no aircraft took off from any airport in the United States. By my own reckoning, which I concede is unaudited, not a single departure went wrong during that period, for the uncomplicated reason that none occurred. I take no pleasure in the disruption to travellers, who deserved far better information than they received on the tarmac. But a regulator that has accidentally achieved a perfect record for departure safety ought at least to study how it was done before rushing to undo it.
Congress will not listen, of course. It will vote the billions, commission a new system, and in due course that system will itself become old, reliable and quietly beloved. Then someone will propose to update it. When that day comes, I ask only that they consult this column first, which I intend to leave exactly as it is.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Left entirely alone3%
- Dusted9%
- Minor patch46%
- Spoken to sharply97%
- Full modernisation99%
- Modernised faster100%
The safest intervention in American air traffic control is, on these figures, no intervention at all.
Source: The Object Daily, estimate made this morning on the back of a boarding pass (unaudited) · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Demand on the system is set by how many people wish to fly, not by how modern the equipment is; refusing to upgrade does not reduce the asking, it merely guarantees the next overload.
The bureaucratic one
Form ATC-0 would itself require a digital submission portal, which would need regular updates, and the bill makes no provision for who may approve the updating of the form that forbids updating.
The absurd one
If grounded aircraft are the safest aircraft, the logical end point is to replace every airport with a car park and declare American aviation perfected.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- technology
- congress
- bureaucracy
- public services

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card