Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026Vol. 1 · No. 9 · Price: one objection
ScienceLeader · SatireObjection

Starship has not failed; it has quietly become America's most dependable airline

The booster missed its catch and landed in the sea. Everyone calls this a setback. A closer reading suggests SpaceX has instead mastered both punctual departures and 1969.

3 min readDisagreement: 3 out of 5, opposedWhat actually happened? ↓
Everyone else
Failing to catch the booster is another setback for Musk's reusable rocket programme.
The Object Daily
On a night when almost nothing in America left the ground, an experimental rocket did, which makes it the country's most reliable carrier, and its booster's splashdown is not failure but a faithful revival of Apollo.

I disagree.

The coverage of Starship’s 15th test flight has fixated on what happened at the end, which is the least interesting part of any journey, as anyone who has collected a suitcase at Heathrow will confirm. Very little attention has been paid to what happened at the beginning. According to NBC News, on an evening when few flights were taking off in the United States, one of those few was a rocket the height of a block of flats, operated by a company that publicly describes its test vehicles as experimental.

Consider what this means for the travelling public. A family with a connection through Denver could not get away that night. Starship could. By the only metric the airline industry truly respects, which is whether the thing left at roughly the time it said it would, SpaceX outperformed the entire domestic carrier network. I have checked my own notes and can find no record of a single Starship passenger complaining about legroom, a missed connection or the price of a sandwich. That none were aboard is, I would argue, a matter of booking policy rather than service quality.

Then there is the booster. The company had caught it three times before, plucking it from the air with a tower in a manoeuvre best described as showing off. This time the catch was aborted and the booster came down in the ocean. The commentariat has filed this under ‘setback’. I would file it under ‘heritage’.

Coming home by way of the sea is, after all, how NASA brought the Apollo astronauts back. Nobody stood on the deck of a recovery ship and called it a disappointment. They called it history. Mr Musk, through no apparent intention of his own, has spent a great deal of money returning American spaceflight to its most celebrated era. He set out to build the future and accidentally achieved 1969, which is more than most people manage with the future.

I accept that a sea landing makes reuse harder. But there is a case that catching a skyscraper in mid-air was never the conservative option. The three previous catches should arguably be treated as the anomalies, and Friday as a return to established best practice, fully compliant with sixty years of precedent and requiring no new chopsticks.

I therefore propose that the Federal Aviation Administration convene a working group on the Reclassification of Suborbital and Orbital Vehicles as Scheduled Passenger Services, with a remit to report within eighteen months. Its first task should be a consultation on whether a vehicle that departs on time and lands in the Gulf qualifies for the Department of Transportation’s on-time performance tables. I suspect it would top them.

Some will say I am confusing reliability with explosiveness. I am not. I am simply observing that, on the night in question, the explosive option was the one that got off the ground. Until the airlines can say the same, they are in no position to call anybody else’s evening a setback.

The Object Daily editorial board

The Object Daily Statistics OfficeFact-checked by ourselvesPassenger complaints per departure, by mode of transport (my estimate)

Complaints per departure

  1. Domestic airliner4.2
  2. Regional coach2.9
  3. Rail replacement bus7.5
  4. Experimental rocket0

No mode of transport has ever generated fewer complaints than a rocket that carries no passengers, which the airlines should study closely.

Source: Object Daily Transport Desk, figures compiled this morning from my own recollection of airports · Satire

Three further objections

  1. The reasonable one

    An airline is judged on carrying people safely to a chosen destination, and a vehicle that carries nobody to an unplanned patch of ocean meets neither test, however punctual its departure.

  2. The bureaucratic one

    Any reclassification as a scheduled passenger service would first require a published timetable, a designated customer complaints officer and a compliant refund policy for flights whose arrival point is 'the sea'.

  3. The absurd one

    If splashing down is merely returning to 1969, then the logical next step is for SpaceX to abort the rocket entirely and achieve the Wright brothers by 2028.

Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

  • space
  • science
  • technology
  • bureaucracy
Quote card: Everyone else: Failing to catch the booster is another setback for Musk's reusable rocket programme. The Object Daily: On a night when almost nothing in America left the ground, an experimental rocket did, which makes it the country's most reliable carrier, and its booster's splashdown is not failure but a faithful revival of Apollo.

The quote card

Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.

Share the quote card

We also disagree with

An even stronger objection

Disagreement 4 out of 5, against this article's 3

Sport15 Nov 2026Disagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposed

Wales's victory over New Zealand has destroyed a priceless national heritage asset

Seventy-three years of dignified defeat against the All Blacks were maintained at enormous cost by generations of Welsh players. They have been demolished in a single afternoon, without planning consent.

Everyone else: Beating New Zealand is a joyous, nation-lifting miracle that proves Welsh rugby is back from the dead.