The Arlington sentinel should be given oversight of the Pentagon, and not before time
A soldier at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier told the Defence Secretary's group to be quiet, and they were. Nothing else in Washington has worked this well all year.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
The episode was an embarrassing display of disrespect by Pete Hegseth's entourage and a fitting rebuke from a soldier doing his duty.- The Object Daily
- It was not an embarrassment but the only demonstrably functioning chain of command in the Pentagon this year, and the sentinel should be placed in charge of overseeing the department.
I must object.
Not to the sentinel, who was entirely correct, nor to the tomb, which deserves every ounce of the silence it is owed. I object to the near-universal verdict that Wednesday’s episode at Arlington was merely an embarrassment for the Department of Defense. Having watched the clip more times than I would care to declare on a register of interests, I have concluded that it was something far rarer. It was the first demonstration this year of a chain of command that works.
Consider the mechanics. A group that included the Defence Secretary was making noise; there was laughter while photographs were being taken. A soldier on duty identified the problem, issued a clear instruction and secured compliance. There was no working group. There was no interim report, no forty-page memorandum circulated for comment with a deadline that slipped twice. The Pentagon’s own spokesman has since confirmed that the sentinel “reminded everyone to maintain decorum”, which, in departmental language, is very nearly a commendation.
Compare this with a typical round of congressional committee hearings. By my estimate, prepared this morning on the back of a parking permit, such a round consumes some 2,300 staff hours, generates several thousand pages of transcript and produces very little measurable change in anyone’s behaviour. The sentinel achieved full compliance in approximately four seconds. Even allowing for the generous margin of error my methodology requires, that is an efficiency gain of roughly two million times.
I therefore propose that oversight of the Department of Defense be transferred, on a trial basis, to the sentinel. The terms of reference would be short. Any senior official found to be conducting himself in a manner beneath the dignity of his office would be told so, once, at volume. Press briefings would be held in the same register. Procurement overruns would be addressed by the sentinel walking twenty-one steps, turning, and waiting for the contractor to explain himself.
It will be said that the sentinel already has a job, and a vastly more important one than auditing the Pentagon. This is true, and it is the strongest argument in my favour. A soldier who guards the tomb with that degree of seriousness has plainly grasped what the department is for, which is more than can be said for an entourage that mistook one of the most solemn places in the country for a backdrop. He should not be asked to leave his post. The Pentagon should simply be moved closer to it.
Happily, it is already less than two miles away, which my officials inform me is within shouting distance on a still day.
I do not ask for a committee, a hearing or a vote. Those are tried every year, at considerable length. I ask only that the department’s next set of performance targets be framed around the one metric shown to work: whether the Secretary and his advisers can stand quietly for a few minutes in a place that asks for nothing else. On Wednesday’s evidence, they will need supervision. Fortunately, it is already on duty.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
Staff hours
- Sentinel (one shout)0
- Press briefing12
- Internal review1,150
- Committee hearings2,300
- Full inquiry (hypoth.)6,800
Measured per unit of silence achieved, a single sentinel outperforms the entire apparatus of congressional oversight by a factor that our statisticians have declined to print.
Source: The Object Daily Office of Comparative Shouting, estimate prepared on the back of a parking permit · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
The sentinel's authority comes precisely from standing outside the department's politics; give him oversight of the Pentagon and you would turn the one figure everyone respects into just another official to be lobbied.
The bureaucratic one
Any transfer of oversight would require amending Title 10 of the United States Code, and each reprimand would have to be logged on the appropriate form in triplicate, followed by a thirty-day public comment period on the permitted decibel level.
The absurd one
The Pentagon cannot be moved closer to Arlington, because it has five sides and only one of them can face the cemetery at a time.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- us politics
- governance
- congress
- military

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card