A ten-year plan is a will, and nobody sensible writes their own will without a professional firm
The prime minister is being mocked for asking management consultants to draft his national blueprint. He should instead be criticised for letting anyone hurry them.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
A prime minister who needs consultants to tell him what he believes, and who then rushes the plan out under pressure, has no plan at all.- The Object Daily
- Outsourcing a ten-year plan is the only honest thing Westminster has done in years, since no government lasts long enough to see one through, and the only real mistake was bringing it forward.
I disagree.
The consensus this week is that a prime minister who asks Boston Consulting Group to draft his ten-year plan has no plan of his own. It adds that a prime minister who then promises to publish it before Christmas, having been teased about it at Prime Minister’s Questions, has even less of one. This is a reasonable view, held by reasonable people. It also misunderstands the ten-year plan entirely.
Consider the genre. By my own count, made this morning with a pencil and a list of prime ministers I keep for emergencies, the ten-year plan is the most reliably unfinished document in British public life. Governments announce them in year one and are back in opposition well before year ten. The plan survives them, like a spare key under a mat outside a house that has since been sold.
The ten-year plan is therefore the only document in Westminster written in the certain knowledge that its authors will not be present at its conclusion. It is less a manifesto than a will. And nobody of sound mind drafts their own will on the kitchen table. They go to a firm with headed notepaper, a filing system and a reasonable expectation of still being in business when the contents are read out.
Seen in this light, handing the blueprint to a consultancy is not abdication. It is rare candour. A government is a tenant. A consultancy, in actuarial terms, is closer to furniture. The partners will rotate, but the slide template endures. If anyone is asked in 2036 whether the milestones for year seven were met, it will not be a minister. It will be somebody with a lanyard who can at least locate the original file.
I would go further. Ten-year plans should be lodged, like pension schemes, with an independent custodian. A short statute should require whoever wrote them to attend a review meeting in the tenth year. I have sketched the relevant clause, Section 4(2)(b), which provides that where the original authors cannot be traced, the meeting shall proceed with the document’s font as the senior surviving representative.
Where the prime minister has genuinely erred is not in outsourcing the plan but in accelerating it. A ten-year plan rushed out before Christmas because of a jibe across the dispatch box is a ten-year plan whose first milestone is surviving January. By bringing it forward, he has reimported the very short-termism the consultants were presumably engaged to remove. The professionals had a timetable. The House of Commons has a Wednesday.
I have therefore written to Downing Street with a modest proposal. The Christmas deadline should be withdrawn, and the plan should be published, as nature intended, in arrears: in 2036, alongside a note confirming which parts happened. It would be the first ten-year plan in British history to meet every one of its targets. I would read it with great interest, and I would not need to object to a word.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Any sitting minister4%
- A consultancy's template91%
- The plan, in a drawer99%
- The year-seven milestone11%
- Christmas deadline0%
Source: · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
The bureaucratic one
The absurd one
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card