Dearer food and cheaper petrol are America's most successful public-health programme in years
October's inflation figures are being read as a story of pain shifted from the pump to the till. They are in fact a wellness strategy of rare ambition, delivered without a single pamphlet.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Prices are still too high, and cheaper petrol merely hides the pain in the grocery aisle.- The Object Daily
- Rising food prices and falling fuel prices together amount to a national programme of eating less and driving further, and Washington should be arguing over who gets the credit.
I disagree.
Everyone has read October’s consumer price index as a tale of misery merely relocated: cheaper at the pump, dearer at the till, nothing gained. This is to read a public-health report as though it were a shopping receipt. What the figures actually describe, on any fair reading, is the most ambitious national wellness scheme Washington has attempted in a generation, delivered at no cost to the federal budget and without a single leaflet.
Consider the mechanism. Petrol falls; food rises. The incentive is unambiguous: drive more, eat less. By an estimate I prepared this morning on the back of an envelope, a household can now cover roughly 1.4 additional miles for every bread roll it forgoes. I do not say this is pleasant. I say it is efficient, which in Washington has always been regarded as the higher virtue. Successive administrations spent decades redesigning the food pyramid, then the food plate. The market has simply repriced the plate.
Thanksgiving will be the scheme’s first full field trial. Americans will set off earlier, travel further on cheaper fuel and arrive with a smaller quantity of everything awaiting them. In any other context this would be called a successful pilot. I understand the Bureau of Labor Statistics does not consider itself a health agency. I merely note that it has outperformed several that do.
Take the luxury pie, now available, I am told, at $150. A less careful observer might treat it as evidence of decadence. It is nothing of the sort. It is evidence that the market has stopped selling dessert and started selling aspiration. Nobody eats a $150 pie. One photographs it, insures it and discusses it at length with relatives. By my analysis, roughly a tenth of the price is attributable to anything edible. Calorie for calorie, it is the healthiest pie ever baked, because it is consumed almost entirely by the eyes.
Washington will now spend the winter arguing over who is to blame for all this. Both parties are asking the wrong question. The correct question is who may claim credit. I fully expect the first business of the new session to be a joint resolution disputing authorship of the national calorie deficit, referred to committee and never seen again.
My one reservation concerns petrol. If fuel continues to fall, Americans will drive so far to Thanksgiving dinner that the pie will have appreciated beyond their means by the time they arrive. The two halves of the programme are, in other words, dangerously out of balance.
I therefore call on the Federal Reserve to abandon its fixation on 2 per cent and adopt a more meaningful target: one pie per tank. Until it does, I shall be driving to dinner slowly. It is considerably cheaper than arriving.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Aspiration64%
- Box and ribbon14%
- Photographability11%
- Filling6%
- Pastry4%
- Actual pie1%
Roughly a tenth of a luxury pie is edible, which makes it the most nutritionally responsible purchase on the Thanksgiving table.
Source: The Object Daily pie audit, conducted by inspection through a shop window · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Households cut back on food not out of health-consciousness but out of necessity, and a fall in spending tells you nothing about what people are actually eating or how well.
The bureaucratic one
The Bureau of Labor Statistics is not authorised to deliver health outcomes, and any wellness benefit must first be submitted for review by the relevant agency under the appropriate interagency memorandum.
The absurd one
If Americans drive far enough on cheap petrol, they will eventually return to their own homes from the other side, at which point Thanksgiving becomes a loop and the pie must be accounted for twice.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- us politics
- white house
- congress
- health

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card