Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026Vol. 1 · No. 9 · Price: one objection
WorldLeader · SatireObjection

America's empty seat at COP31 is the finest emissions cut any summit has ever produced

For thirty years nations have flown to climate conferences to promise less carbon. This year the United States has delivered some, simply by staying at home, and the rest of the world should take note.

2 min readDisagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposedWhat actually happened? ↓
Everyone else
America's absence from COP31 is a shameful abdication that weakens the talks, and Democrats turning up unofficially is a welcome sign of hope.
The Object Daily
By sending no official delegation, the United States has achieved the only verifiable, unconditional and fully delivered emissions reduction in the history of the COP process.

I must object.

Not to the heat, which I accept, nor to the scientists, who have measured it with admirable care and found the planet accumulating warmth at an accelerating rate, rather as the Treasury accumulates consultation responses. I object to the near-universal view that the absence of an official American delegation from COP31 in Antalya is a shameful abdication. It is, on the contrary, the most effective emissions reduction any country has delivered at a climate summit in thirty years of trying.

Consider the arithmetic. According to an estimate I made this morning with a pencil and an airline seat map, a full national delegation (negotiators, advisers, press officers, the official who carries the lanyards) generates around 480 tonnes of carbon dioxide getting to a COP and back. The largest delegations manage several times that. The official United States contribution to this year’s total is zero. Not reduced. Not offset. Zero. No pledge has ever achieved that, and no communiqué has come close.

Critics say that by staying away America forfeits influence over the negotiating text. I have read a number of negotiating texts, and I would gently observe that influence over them has historically been measured in square brackets rather than degrees Celsius. The country that has emitted more carbon dioxide than any other in history has now stumbled upon the one climate measure that cannot be watered down in a side room at four in the morning: not being in the side room.

I therefore propose that all 190 countries follow the example. COP32 should be convened in full, with a host, an agenda and a closing plenary, but with no delegations whatsoever. Positions could be submitted on a standard form (I suggest Form COP-1, Declaration of Intended Ambition (Non-Attendance)), and the final text agreed by the traditional method of everyone announcing that it went rather well. Turkey’s commendable ambition to make electricity a far larger share of global energy demand could be advanced at once by switching off the conference centre.

The host has asked for progress that people can see is real. I can think of nothing more visible than an empty chair. It photographs well, it requires no visa and it has never once been accused of backsliding.

Which brings me, with some reluctance, to the Democrats who have travelled to Antalya unofficially. I have no quarrel with their enthusiasm. My difficulty is one of accounting. An unofficial delegation’s emissions are by definition unofficial, and therefore, under any reporting framework I am familiar with, do not exist. This is either a dangerous loophole or a historic breakthrough, and Whitehall would no doubt call it both, in separate annexes.

Naturally, I did not attend either. I have written this column at my desk, under a single lamp, which I shall now switch off in solidarity. Readers who wish to follow my example are invited to stop reading at this point. It will be the most useful thing any of us does all fortnight.

The Object Daily editorial board

The Object Daily Statistics OfficeAs good as anyone else's factsTravel emissions per delegation to COP31, by this newspaper's estimate

Tonnes of CO2

  1. Very large delegation2,100
  2. Average delegation480
  3. Host nation35
  4. US official delegation0
  5. US unofficial delegation0
  6. This newspaper0

The only delegations to reach net zero are those that did not officially exist.

Source: Pencil, airline seat map and an estimate made this morning; unofficial emissions recorded as non-existent in line with Form COP-1 guidance · Satire

Three further objections

  1. The reasonable one

    A delegation's flights are a rounding error next to a country's annual emissions, so staying at home saves a few hundred tonnes while giving up any say over the billions that actually matter.

  2. The bureaucratic one

    Form COP-1 cannot be processed unless an accredited delegate attends in person to sign the declaration of non-attendance, in triplicate, at the registration desk in Antalya.

  3. The absurd one

    If every country stays away, the conference centre's empty seats will grow lonely, and lonely chairs are known to give off heat of their own.

Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

  • climate
  • us politics
  • governance
  • bureaucracy
Quote card: Everyone else: America's absence from COP31 is a shameful abdication that weakens the talks, and Democrats turning up unofficially is a welcome sign of hope. The Object Daily: By sending no official delegation, the United States has achieved the only verifiable, unconditional and fully delivered emissions reduction in the history of the COP process.

The quote card

Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.

Share the quote card

We also disagree with