If Nato membership now has a price, Washington should publish the tariff, starting with its own
The reported offer of territory for Article 5 has been called cynical. It is worse than that: it is a pricing model nobody has had the courage to write down.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Swapping Ukrainian land for Nato membership is a cynical trade that rewards aggression, dressed up as 'many ideas continue to be discussed'.- The Object Daily
- The dealmakers' fault is not cynicism but timidity, because a price list that nobody publishes cannot be checked, and one that is published would send the bill to the wrong address.
I must object.
Not, I hasten to add, on the grounds most commentators have chosen. According to President Zelensky, the United States has asked whether Ukraine would withdraw from parts of the Donbas if Kyiv were admitted to Nato. The general view is that this is cynical. My view is that it is unfinished. If admission to the alliance can be paid for, then Nato has at last acquired a pricing model, and a pricing model that nobody is allowed to see is not a model. It is a rumour with a till.
Consider the official American response, as given to the BBC: “many ideas continue to be discussed”. That is the sentence a shop assistant uses when you ask why nothing has a price on it. Trading standards would take a dim view. Any organisation that charges for membership, whether the National Trust, the Caravan Club or my local leisure centre, publishes its rates, its terms and the date on which they lapse.
I have therefore drafted a tariff this morning, on the back of a consultation document I was meant to be reading. It offers Article 5 Standard, Article 5 Premium with priority Article 4 consultations, an annual subscription payable in kilometres of coastline, and a loyalty card stamped at every summit, with the tenth communiqué free. It is, I concede, grotesque. But it is grotesque in writing, which is more than can be said for the current arrangement.
And the moment one writes it down, the flaw is plain. A price list assumes the customer pays out of its own pocket. Here the product is offered by Washington, the fee is collected by Moscow, and the payment is drawn from somebody else’s home. In retail there is a word for a vendor who sets the price, a stranger who pockets it and a customer who pays with his own furniture, and the word is not diplomacy.
A published tariff also has the inconvenient property of applying to everyone. If membership now costs territory, then the founding members, who joined in 1949 without paying a square inch, are in arrears. By my calculation, compounding at a modest 2.5 per cent a year, the United States currently owes roughly six and three-quarter Rhode Islands. I await the invoice with interest, as, presumably, does Providence.
Next week Mr Trump, Mr Putin and Mr Xi are due to meet in Shenzhen, where Ukraine is reportedly not expected to come up. I propose that it should, in the narrow form of a single document: the tariff, with Washington’s arrears in column one and Moscow listed under “vendors not authorised to collect”.
Until that document appears, I shall treat land-for-membership exactly as the official described it: one of many ideas that continue to be discussed. It is the correct category. I would only ask that the discussion continue for a very long time, somewhere well away from anyone’s actual map.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
Rhode Islands
Under any honestly published price list, the first invoice goes to Washington.
Source: Object Daily Tariff Unit, calculated this morning on the back of an unread consultation document · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Publishing a tariff would turn a dubious private idea into an official precedent, and the whole point of leaving it as 'many ideas' may be that nobody wants to own it.
The bureaucratic one
Territorial subscriptions cannot be accepted until the alliance's finance committee agrees whether coastline is measured at high or low tide, and which month counts as the start of the billing year.
The absurd one
Rhode Island has already written to say it is not available in instalments and would prefer to be paid in Delaware.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- diplomacy
- military
- us politics
- white house

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card