Europe should treat its exclusion from the great-power summit as a diplomatic triumph
The leaders of America, Russia and China will meet without Europe next week. This is not a snub. It is the most valuable thing a bloc can be given: an alibi.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Europe is horrified at being left out of a summit where three strongmen may carve up the world without it.- The Object Daily
- Not being invited is the oldest and most reliable way of not being blamed, and Europe should stop jeopardising it by minding.
I must object.
Not on the grounds most commonly advanced. Next week, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen, the leaders of America, Russia and China will meet as a trio for the first time. The agenda, we are told, includes the reduction of nuclear weapons and the war against Iran. Europe, which is not on the guest list, is said to be horrified. It is the horror I object to.
Being left out of a meeting is not a slight. It is the single most valuable status in diplomacy, and it is very hard to obtain. Every civil servant knows this. The person who attends the meeting owns the minutes. The person who sends apologies owns a clean record. In Whitehall this is known, informally, as the Doctrine of Regrettable Unavailability, and entire careers have been built upon it.
According to an estimate I made this morning with an envelope and a ruler, roughly 71 per cent of the blame for any summit’s outcome falls on those in the room, 18 per cent on those loitering in the corridor, 9 per cent on those who issued a statement beforehand, and 2 per cent on those who were not invited at all. That final 2 per cent is almost entirely accounted for by people who complained loudly about not being invited.
Consider what Brussels has been spared. Ordinarily, to disclaim responsibility for something, the European Union must convene a working group, circulate a non-paper, open a consultation, translate the consultation into twenty-odd languages and then issue a position paper explaining that it has no position. Even then it is usually held partly responsible. On this occasion the same result has been achieved by the simple expedient of not being asked. Several stages of the ordinary legislative procedure have been skipped, and nobody has noticed.
Britain, I observe, has secured the identical outcome independently, which makes it the first common foreign-policy result London and Brussels have shared in some time. I would call this a reset, were I not worried that someone might then want to hold a meeting about it.
The danger, therefore, lies entirely in the horror. To be horrified is to express an interest; to express an interest is to have a view; to have a view is to be asked, afterwards, what one did about it. If the summit goes well, Europe will be asked why it contributed nothing. If it goes badly, Europe will be asked why it did not intervene. The only safe answer to both is we were not invited, and that answer is forfeited the moment one is seen to have minded.
I had intended to close by urging the Commission to send a short note of thanks to the organisers. On reflection, a note is correspondence, and correspondence is a paper trail. I have therefore drafted it and placed it in a drawer, which is where Europe’s finest diplomacy belongs.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- In the room71%
- In the corridor18%
- Issued a statement9%
- Not invited2%
The cheapest seat at any summit is the one nobody offered you, provided you do not complain about it.
Source: Estimate made this morning by The Object Daily using an envelope and a ruler · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Blame may be allocated by attendance, but consequences are not: if three nuclear powers settle matters of European security, Europe lives with the result whether or not it is on the minutes.
The bureaucratic one
Under internal procedures, a formal decision not to react to a non-invitation must itself be minuted and agreed by all member states, which constitutes a position and therefore requires a position paper.
The absurd one
Europe was in fact invited, but the invitation was routed to the consultations inbox, where it remains open for public comment until the spring.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- diplomacy
- european union
- us politics

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card