Reinstate Jensen Huang: he is the only chief executive in America whose security risk has been fully audited
While the critics talk of consequences and the admirers talk of the AI race, both have missed the point. A foreign intelligence service has already done Nvidia's due diligence for it, and at no cost to shareholders.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
A comeback for Jensen Huang would prove either that tech titans face no consequences or that America cannot win the AI race without him.- The Object Daily
- Mr Huang should be reinstated precisely because of the scandal, since an executive already targeted by a foreign intelligence service is the only one whose risk profile is actually known.
I disagree.
Not with the critics, who say that bringing Jensen Huang back to Nvidia would show that tech titans face no consequences, and not with his admirers in Silicon Valley, who say the AI race cannot be won without him. Both camps are arguing about character. The proper subject is vetting.
When a company appoints a chief executive, it commissions a headhunter, takes up a few references and asks the nominations committee to form a view over lunch. When, as US officials say, a foreign intelligence service takes an interest in a man, it brings to bear resources that no board could hope to approve in a single budget cycle. Mr Huang has, in short, been examined more closely than any other executive in America, and the examination was free.
Consider the alternative. Any replacement is, from a security point of view, an unknown quantity. Nobody knows who has approached them, when, or with what result. Mr Huang is the only chief executive in the country for whom at least part of that answer is already in the newspapers. Insurers will happily price a known risk. It is the unknown ones they decline.
According to an estimate I made this morning, the typical candidate receives around 11 hours of meaningful scrutiny before appointment. I arrived at the comparable figure for Mr Huang by multiplying the headhunter’s fee by the number of government agencies now involved, and it is considerably larger. Add a summons from Congress, and there is simply no more thoroughly audited man in the industry. Any successor would need years to catch up.
Nor is it true that reinstatement would mean no consequences. The consequence would be that every meeting he attends is minuted, discreetly, by at least three governments. That is a level of accountability shareholders normally only read about in governance reports. I have drafted a framework for it, the Previously Targeted Executive Retention Protocol, whose Form PTE-4 requires him to declare each new acquaintance in triplicate, with a fourth copy for whichever agency happens to ask first.
As for the AI race, I object to that argument as well. Whether or not the race can be won without him is beside the point. The question for a board is not genius but exposure, and his exposure has already been mapped, measured and, I assume, filed.
Should the board nevertheless decline, I propose a compromise. Nvidia should advertise the vacancy with one additional line in the person specification: applicants who have not yet been approached by a hostile state need not apply. Anything less would be unvetted.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
- Shareholder AGM0.5 h
- Headhunter6 h
- Nominations committee11 h
- Congressional hearing40 h
- Foreign intelligence2,900 h
Measured purely by hours of scrutiny, no successor can compete with a man who has already been vetted by a foreign state.
Source: The Object Daily's estimate, made this morning by multiplying a headhunter's fee by the number of agencies involved · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Being targeted tells you what an intelligence service wanted, not how the target behaved, and a board is supposed to judge the second, not the first.
The bureaucratic one
Form PTE-4 has not been through the Commerce Department's clearance process, and the requirement to submit in triplicate conflicts with the agency's paperless-office directive.
The absurd one
If being targeted counts as vetting, then the most qualified candidate for the job would logically be the alleged spy herself, and the nominations committee is not ready for that conversation.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- technology
- cybersecurity
- governance
- artificial intelligence

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card