Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026Vol. 1 · No. 9 · Price: one objection
WorldLeader · SatireObjection

Europe's exclusion from the Abu Dhabi talks is its finest diplomatic achievement and must be protected

As American, Russian and Ukrainian delegations reconvene in the Gulf, European ministers are lobbying for a seat. They have failed to grasp that absence is the only diplomatic position that can never be blamed for anything.

2 min readDisagreement: 4 out of 5, strongly opposedWhat actually happened? ↓
Everyone else
Expectations in Abu Dhabi are low, Moscow shows no appetite for peace, and Europe's exclusion from talks about its own security is a humiliation.
The Object Daily
Being left out of a negotiation is the one foreign policy Europe can execute flawlessly, and it would be reckless to abandon it now.

I disagree.

Not with the facts, which are plain enough. Delegations from Washington, Moscow and Kyiv are meeting in Abu Dhabi for the first trilateral talks since February, and G7 foreign ministers gathered in Paris have been pressing the US Secretary of State for a role. Commentators call Europe’s exclusion humiliating. I call it the most successful European foreign policy initiative in a generation, and I would ask its authors kindly to stop trying to ruin it.

Consider what a seat at the table actually involves. A seat at the table is a liability with a name card. Once seated, one is photographed; once photographed, one is quoted; once quoted, one is responsible. I am not aware of a single history textbook that criticises a delegation for failing to attend a conference to which it was not invited.

The arithmetic is unforgiving. According to an estimate I made this morning with a ruler and a school atlas, culpability for any negotiated outcome falls by roughly thirty percentage points for every thousand miles a delegation stands from the table. Paris lies some 3,260 miles from Abu Dhabi, which leaves European ministers with a residual blame of about two per cent. I attribute this entirely to the press release.

Exclusion has a further virtue. It requires no unanimity among twenty-seven member states, no impact assessment, no trilogue and no qualified majority. It can be implemented on a Tuesday, and indeed has been. After decades of summits that concluded with communiqués nobody could agree on, Brussels has at last found a foreign policy it can carry out flawlessly.

I note that the American proposal reportedly includes a long-term security architecture between Moscow and Europe. This suggests that the architects are already at work and that Europe has been cast as the building. I would gently observe that buildings are rarely consulted on their own design, and are seldom blamed when the roof leaks.

Rather than lobbying, I propose that European capitals establish a permanent Office of Strategic Absence. Its staff would maintain a rota of ministers ready to issue statements welcoming whatever emerges, noting any difficulties and regretting not having been consulted, in that order. The texts could be drafted in advance in all twenty-four official languages, which would represent a considerable saving on interpreters.

I should add, with the gravity the subject demands, that none of this concerns the people who live with the consequences of the war. They deserve talks that work, wherever they are held and whoever attends. My objection is confined to the ministers in Paris, whose principal anxiety appears to be not the outcome but the seating plan.

My advice to Europe is therefore simple. Stay away, stay blameless, and above all do not ask for a chair. Someone might give you one.

The Object Daily editorial board

The Object Daily Statistics OfficeFact-checked by ourselvesShare of blame for a negotiated outcome, by distance from the table

Every mile between a minister and the negotiating table is a mile of moral safety, and Paris is very nearly far enough.

Source: The Object Daily, ruler and school atlas, estimate made this morning · Satire

Three further objections

  1. The reasonable one

    A party absent from the negotiation may escape blame, but it also forfeits any influence over a settlement whose security consequences it will have to live with regardless.

  2. The bureaucratic one

    The proposed Office of Strategic Absence would itself require a seat on the relevant Council working party, thereby placing Europe at a table and triggering the very culpability it was established to avoid.

  3. The absurd one

    If distance reduces blame, Europe should relocate its foreign ministers to New Zealand for the duration, though this risks making Wellington responsible for everything.

Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.

  • european union
  • us politics
  • governance
  • diplomacy
Quote card: Everyone else: Expectations in Abu Dhabi are low, Moscow shows no appetite for peace, and Europe's exclusion from talks about its own security is a humiliation. The Object Daily: Being left out of a negotiation is the one foreign policy Europe can execute flawlessly, and it would be reckless to abandon it now.

The quote card

Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.

Share the quote card

We also disagree with