Spain's general strike was not a protest. It was the first time anyone got their money's worth out of a flat
Millions of Spanish workers stayed away from work on Wednesday in protest at the cost of housing. They have accidentally solved the problem of their rent's value, if not of its size.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Spain's housing crisis has become unbearable, and tourists, landlords and investors have priced ordinary people out of their own cities.- The Object Daily
- The general strike was the most efficient use of an unaffordable flat yet devised, and the only mistake was leaving the house.
I disagree.
Not with the strikers, whose grievance is plain enough, but with the commentators who have spent the past day describing Wednesday as a protest. It was nothing of the sort. By my reckoning, it was the first occasion in a decade on which a substantial portion of the Spanish workforce actually used the accommodation it pays for.
Consider the arithmetic. I have assumed a city-centre rent of €1,400 a month, a figure I settled on this morning and see no reason to revisit. On an ordinary weekday the tenant spends perhaps four waking hours in the flat, most of them standing in front of an open fridge or looking for keys. That comes to €11.67 per waking hour, roughly the rate at a modest hotel bar. On Wednesday, a tenant who stayed in for sixteen waking hours brought the figure down to €2.92. No government programme has ever cut effective housing costs so far in a single day. The Treasury here would call it a policy triumph and commission a review into why it cannot be repeated.
The conventional analysis, in other words, has things backwards. Rents are not too high. Occupancy is too low. A flat let at €1,400 and lived in for a sixth of the day is a luxury product going to waste. The tourist paying considerably more for a week in the same building understands this by instinct. He arrives, he occupies, he stays in until noon. The resident is the only party to the arrangement who leaves every morning to earn the money for a room he will not see in daylight.
This is why I must register my disappointment with those who went out. Reports from Barcelona and elsewhere describe crowds in the streets, fireworks, burning bins and riot police. I do not say this to belittle anyone’s anger, which seems to me entirely proportionate to the price of a two-bedroom flat in Gràcia. I say only that every hour spent outside was an hour of rent going unused. The bins, which are municipal property and pay no rent at all, were the least deserving recipients of anyone’s attention.
The governments of Europe will now respond in the customary way: an inter-ministerial working group, a 140-page consultation on rent controls, and a pledge to build an impressive number of homes by a year ending in zero. I propose something cheaper. Every tenant should be issued one statutory Occupancy Day a month, on which they are entitled to remain at home for the full twenty-four hours and extract the full value of their tenancy. Employers will object. Landlords will object more strongly, since a tenant who is home all day eventually notices the damp.
I accept that this does nothing about prices. Neither, so far, has anything else. It at least has the merit of being measurable, which is more than can be said for most housing strategies I have read, and I have read a great many on trains.
There is one further matter. The commentators keep calling Wednesday a day on which Spain stopped working and stayed at home. They should be more precise. The landlords did not join the strike. They did not need to. They are the only people in Spain who stay at home every day of the week and are paid handsomely for it.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
Euros per hour
- Day with overtime46.67
- Strike day, went marching23.33
- Ordinary weekday11.67
- Weekend4.67
- Strike day, stayed in2.92
The cheapest way to live in a Spanish flat is to refuse to leave it.
Source: The Object Daily Housing Utilisation Unit, from an estimate made this morning over toast · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
Rent is a fixed cost, already paid whether or not anyone is in, so dividing it by hours at home describes the sunk-cost fallacy rather than any saving.
The bureaucratic one
A statutory Occupancy Day would need a Form OD1 countersigned by the landlord, a certificate of continuous presence, and a regional inspectorate to confirm that the tenant did not pop out for bread.
The absurd one
If every resident stays in all day, the tourists will have no locals to photograph, and the tourism ministry will have to hire actors to stand about looking authentically priced out.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- housing
- spain
- strikes
- governance

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card