Sacking managers is the one thing United do well, and it deserves a proper quarterly timetable
Manchester United are expected to part company with their head coach after their worst start in 40 years. The Object Daily argues that the club's only reliable department is being shamefully underused.
A message from the editorsVote against us ↓
- Everyone else
Pundits agree that Michael Carrick has failed and must go so that Manchester United can finally rebuild.- The Object Daily
- Dismissing head coaches is Manchester United's single area of excellence, and it should be formalised as a fixed quarterly rota, budgeted for like VAT.
I must object.
Not to the expected dismissal of Michael Carrick, which appears by every available account to be imminent, but to the tone in which it is being discussed. Pundits speak of failure and of rebuilding, as though the departure of a head coach at Manchester United were some sort of emergency. It is nothing of the kind. It is the club’s core competence.
Consider the record. For the better part of a decade, United have struggled to sign a midfielder, defend a corner or explain what their various directors are for. Yet throughout this period one function has operated with the reliability of a Swiss railway: the removal of the man in charge. The statement is drafted, the compensation is calculated, the interim is located. Nobody misses a deadline. Any management consultant would identify this as the organisation’s single area of excellence, and any competent management consultant would invoice handsomely for saying so.
In a well-run business, strengths are protected. They are not left to the whim of results. Yet United continue to treat dismissal as reactive, triggered by a bad run, a damp Tuesday or the worst start to a domestic campaign in 40 years. This is the behaviour of a club that has found its best department and refuses to give it a proper calendar.
I therefore propose the Quarterly Head Coach Rotation Scheme. A new head coach would be appointed on the first working day of each quarter and dismissed, with warm thanks, on the last. The termination payment would be accrued monthly and filed alongside the VAT return, so that the finance department need never again be surprised by something that arrives about as predictably as the seasons.
The advantages are considerable. Candidates would know precisely when their tenure ends, which is more certainty than most have been offered. Supporters could buy scarves with the head coach’s name printed in removable vinyl. The press could pre-write the ‘expected to be sacked’ article and simply update the league position. Results would cease to bear on the employment question at all, freeing the head coach to concentrate on the football, which is, I am told, the point.
Naturally there must be oversight. I suggest a Dismissals Sub-Committee of the board, meeting quarterly with a standing agenda of one item, and obliged to publish an annual Statement of Departure Readiness. Should a head coach win four consecutive matches mid-quarter, a review would be convened – not to extend his contract, which would undermine the scheme, but to establish what went wrong.
The pundits say United must sack their head coach so that they can finally rebuild. They have it backwards. United have been rebuilding continuously for ten years; it is the only construction project at Old Trafford that is ever finished on time. The board should stop apologising for it and start budgeting for it. And if the scheme itself should underperform, I would of course expect it to be replaced at the end of the quarter.
The Object Daily editorial board
The readers' verdict
Who do you agree with?
agree with everyone else agree with The Object Daily
Consistency score out of 10
- Dismissing head coaches9.6
- Drafting exit statements9.1
- Locating interim coaches8.4
- Signing midfielders3.1
- Defending corners2.4
- Explaining the structure1.2
The data are unambiguous: the club should invest in its one department that works and stop pretending the others are the priority.
Source: Object Daily Unit for Departmental Excellence, estimate compiled over breakfast · Satire
Three further objections
The reasonable one
A fixed quarterly rota would make every head coach a lame duck from the first day, and players would simply wait each one out, which is arguably the problem the club already has.
The bureaucratic one
Termination payments cannot be filed alongside the VAT return, as they are not a taxable supply, and the proposal would therefore require a separate quarterly schedule, form, and guidance note.
The absurd one
Quarters are far too long; a club of United's ambition should move to a monthly cycle, with the head coach rotated alphabetically among season-ticket holders.
Satire. This article was written by AI from real news headlines. The opinions are invented and deliberately contrary. The Object Daily does not claim that any of this is true, wise or even reasonable. Our editorial standards.
- football
- premier league
- governance
- bureaucracy

The quote card
Everyone else versus The Object Daily, ready to paste wherever people are agreeing with each other.
Share the quote card